QCAD.org Forum

Can this be done using the Qcad Cam combination for purchase? I have a simple cylinder that I want to engrave single line text onto a curved surface of course. I'm hoping Qcad will have a simpler process to do this.

I've been trying for a week using Freecad to do this without success. Been using different Ai servers to get assistance along with youtube videos and looking on the forum. With each version update so did the process and functions required to to do this. It's straight forward with a flat surface but not so much with a curved surface.

Thanks,
Dave

Not out of the box.

The cylinder axis (probably A or B) is usually controlled in degrees, so you would be looking at a post processor that outputs for example the X axis in millimeter and the Y axis as A axis converted from millimeter to degrees (depending on the diameter of the piece).

Circular movements (on the X/Y plane G02/G03) are often interpolated with line segments. QCAD/CAM can do that for you.

So, yes, it can be done with QCAD/CAM but a custom post processor is required that implements the above.

If I was to purchase Qcad CAM where would this custom post processor come from? I purchased Qcad a couple years back and didn't have the need to upgrade since then.

You would typically provide working example G-code for your machine / controller and we would quote you on how much that would be to implement. This effort can vary greatly from half an hour for a pretty straight forward post processor to several hours for more complex setups.

Hi,

It also depends on your CNC-driver and software.
I would first consult its documentation in detail.
Mine has the capability to map Y motions to a 4th rotational A-axis. (EdingCNC)
The radius or diameter is then a driver parameter.

A bit tricky to set it up correctly but once the initialization is done it is like engraving in the XY plane.
Converting from flatbed to rotational axis and back is then the hardest part.

The problem I had is that I can only set up the 4th rotational axis as parallel with Y, the center line is then fixed in X.
My spindle driver and chuck or face-plate don't fit under my X bridge, only the tail stock and work-piece do.
Essentially I had to map X to A and that was not an option, I then swapped the driver outputs X with Y and rotated the DXF data.
I could also have rotated my coordinate system virtually but that posed other problems.

Another advantage of my diver soft is that it includes a simple CAM and almost cuts directly from DXF.

For starting up, just fool your Z height so that initially it cuts air.
If all seems fine one can zero the cutter in Z on the cylindrical work-piece.
When the diameter is not really uniform, you first need to probe the surface for a grid-like Z-compensation data file.
There is no cylindrical remapping required because the driver already considers all to be flat.

Circular motions (G2/3) should not be a problem.
Because all XY motions are simply mapped to the cylindrical surface.

With every type of motion involving an A-axis rotation the stress on your cutter is quite different so be gently.

I would not say that it is straight forward with a flat surface ... Define flat.
With an engraver point the depth of cut defines the width of cut.
A minute difference of the actual depth into the material may have a larger impact on the width.
It gets more complex on a cylinder because the depth is the center depth and not the cutter edge depth.
For a conical engraver point it is best that you draw yourself an example of a cross-cut.

Regards,
CVH