← All bug reports

FS#602QCad 3 : Intersection between ellipses

Type
Bug
Status
Closed
Resolution
Fixed
Category
QCAD (main)
Severity
Low
Priority
Low
Reported version
3 RC5
Operating system
Windows (All)
Reported
2012-05-23 by plgarcia
Closed
2012-05-31 by andrew

Intersection between ellipses are not all detected.

This makes difficult difficult to make the projection as the example I give, where part of ellipses are to be removed betwwen intersection ponts.

Comments (3)

andrew 2012-05-23

Could you please attach the DXF or DWG file for testing or send it to us via e-mail? Thanks.

deleted user 2012-05-28

I tested this and drew something similar. I found that I needed to explode the ellipses twice in order to break them back down into arcs.I was then able to clean up the drawing with the modify tools!
I guess being able to snap to/detect elliptical 'arc' intersections before exploding them would indeed speed up the 'clean-up' process

plgarcia 2012-05-29

I made some further tests.

If you draw an ellipse and copy and paste this ellipse the intersections are not found. If you re-size the ellipse moving and handle, then the intersections are found again.

My original drawing was done projecting 2 circles, so all ellipses are identical (direction and size). If you draw separately two ellipses exactly the same size and direction, then the intersections are not found.

If you re-size one of the ellipse or draw 2 different ellipses then intersections are found.

To summarize, intersection between two identical ellipses are not found.

Closure comment

r21626